Concept, Design, and Theoretical Material by
Joseph N. Hilton, Ph.D.


Click HERE now to download a Free PDF of The Organizing Adventure of Life.

i Dr. Hilton's i

Writing-to-Learn Adventures

Have You Found the Organizing Adventure for Your Life Yet?

Writing-to-Learn
Adventure #2
: The Worldview Layer of the Mind
The Key to Surviving, Thriving, and Living the Good Life


(Coming Soon! Also Completely FREE When It's Ready)



Reserved for Ads

 

 


 

Reserved for Links to
User Comments:

Home Schooling
College Writing Courses
High School Writing Courses

 

Reserved for Links to: Participating/
Recommended Writing Programs

 

The Organizing Adventure of Life
Understand Yourself and Other People and Make Your Love Life Work


 

Case #1:
Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth Bennett, etc.
in Pride and Prejudice

by
Joseph N. Hilton, Ph.D.



I am a Jane Austen fan. For decades, I read her novels — all of them — a couple of times a year or more. But her six novels have been turned into such excellent visual productions that I watch DVDs now instead of reading.

The DVD version of Pride and Prejudice from A&E/BBC is my favorite (although the lack of closed captioning is a real flaw).

You will learn a lot at this Web site about egocentricity because you have to thoroughly understand the concept in order to sort out other people and the organizing adventures of their lives.

That is the reason for the emphasis on Jane Austen here. She was the world's greatest authority on the subject. She explored and delineated the widest variety of egocentric behavior in the characters that she created.

Most of the problems that her heroines have to deal with originate in someone else's egocentric behavior. She knew the subject from A to Z, and reading her novels a number of times is probably the best and easiest way to get an education on the subject.

You do, of course, learn things better when you learn them the hard way. But hard experience is a hard teacher.

 

One of the most useful things about Jane Austen is that she makes the driving, habitual mindset of her characters absolutely clear in terms of the way it affects their behavior — and she also frequently gives us the rationalizations that they use to conceal their motives from themselves. This clarity about the motivating drives of behavior and the masks of rationalization is important here because it is the thing that makes it so easy to understand so many of her characters in terms of the organizing adventure of their lives.

Applying the organizing adventure concept to Mr. Darcy, for example, is very straightforward. In the first part of Pride and Prejudice, he organizes his life in terms of the social status adventure. He considers personal relationships, especially in the matter of marriage, strictly in terms of social repercussions, family social position and reputation, and the potential for one to to enhance, or at least publicly confirm, one's social position.

With this point of view firmly fixed as his automatic frame of reference, he simply can't wrap his mind around the possibility that anyone would choose to marry into a family with the obvious social and economic handicaps of the Bennetts — not to mention the fact that marriage to any of the Bennett women would involve becoming related to the mother of the family, who seems to have a complete void where one expects to find the social and personal graces.

Such considerations as how intelligent, attractive, socially accomplished, and downright decent Jane and Elizabeth might be are completely irrelevant to Mr. Darcy in the first part of the work. Indeed, he is astounded and dismayed, right through his first marriage proposal to Elizabeth, to find that he is irresistibly attracted to her. His own actions disturb him.

What he discovers is that Elizabeth isn't going to have anything to do with anyone as shallow and insensitive to the needs of other people as he has become. It is, of course, the organizing adventure that Mr. Darcy has chosen to guide him through life that has made him as shallow and insensitive as he is.

We see very little of the process of his transformation from one organizing adventure to another, but the final result is dramatic. Over a period of some months, he does manage to change himself. He makes the love adventure the organizing adventure of his life and comes to terms with what that means in the way of new attitudes and habitual patterns of behavior.

Why does he do it?

It almost certainly isn't just the fact that he can't get Elizabeth to marry him in the sorry inner state that he has fallen into. The source of his transformation is most likely the concatenation of that fact with other facts: The fact that Elizabeth so firmly and positively rejects him, the fact that she so clearly does not regard him as a decent sort of person and can give him her reasons in such unsettling detail (misguided as she is in some parts), the fact that he is profoundly unattracted to women (like the sisters of his friend Mr. Bingley) whose perceptions are governed by the same organizing adventure that he has adopted, and the fact that his organizing adventure has led him to stoop so such miserable behavior as actually concealing matters from his friend Mr. Bingley (specifically, the information that Elizabeth's sister Jane was in London all winter, where Mr. Bingley was, too.)

Sorting through all of these things, Mr. Darcy seems to have asked himself, "What the hell have I been doing?" And he seems to come to the conclusion that he just doesn't want to be the kind of person he is. What he discovers that he wants most out of life is a woman to love whom he can respect and admire for her intelligence, taste, and general good sense, instead of for the superficial qualities that he has fallen into the habit of focusing upon.

He discovers upon reflection that he has found in Elizabeth Bennett exactly the woman who suits him and changes the organizing adventure of his life to a love adventure — which in turn changes his attitudes and values and behavior and the choices that he makes.

As his new character unfolds, Elizabeth Bennett is in a position to witness the fruits of his transformation and to benefit from them. Her opinion of him changes dramatically, he offers again to marry her, and she accepts his second proposal.


Elizabeth Bennett has chosen love as the organizing adventure of her life long before the story opens. She tells her sister that she will only marry for love, and she makes the point absolutely clear in her refusals, first of Mr. Collins and then of Mr. Darcy. In contrast, her friend Charlotte Lucas (who married Mr. Collins) is willing to marry strictly for social position and economic security, which is obviously the organizing adventure of her life.

Elizabeth also makes it clear in her first attitude towards Mr. Wickham that she is not insensitive to economic necessities. As attracted to Mr. Wickham as she is in the early part of the work, she has no interest in marrying him, purely as a practical economic matter. Unlike her youngest sister (who does marry Mr. Wickham), she is aware that a happy marriage requires a certain minimum of economic resources to support it. Without that prospect, she is unwilling even to think about marriage.

She pursues the ideal of her love adventure consistently throughout the novel and winds up with what she wants, once she unwittingly drives Mr. Darcy to adopt the love adventure as the organizing adventure of his life, too, and become the sort of person she can love.


Mrs. Bennett is a more interesting case than she may seem to be on the surface. She is, I admit, an obnoxious, overbearing, irritating, tasteless, stupid person. The organizing adventure in her life, as she appears in the novel, is raising her daughters and getting them married, and like most stupid people, all of her efforts are counterproductive. Having her on your side is just about equivalent to having two people of average intelligence who are out to do you harm.

There are two basic distinctions that apply to all of the adventures in life:

(1) Whether they are carried out intelligently or unintelligently and

(2) Whether they have a purely egocentric focus or are at least tempered by some real concern for the welfare of others.

Mrs. Bennett is not only just about as unintelligent as people who can still function in society get to be. She is also almost purely egocentric. In her own view, of course, she isn't that way. She is working as best she can to help her daughters do well in life. But as you would expect of an egocentric, she is totally incapable of understanding that her version of what her daughters need to do well in life may not be what they want (as her behavior when Elizabeth rejects Mr. Collins' proposal clearly shows). And matters go just about the way you would expect them to go for a pure egocentric who is on the stupid side of the dividing line in humanity: Her efforts to help her daughters do them more harm than good.

In her egocentric behavior, she is very much like the early Mr. Darcy, who knows what is best for his friend Bingley and manipulates Mr. Bingley's life accordingly. The difference is that the early Mr. Darcy is an intelligent egocentric. But his own organizing adventure at that stage (the social status adventure) points him exactly in the wrong direction to be of any real benefit to his friend. All he manages to do is to make his friend miserable.

As for Mrs. Bennett, the thing that makes her case more interesting than it might be at first glance for most people is the fact that her concern for her daughters' welfare has a solid basis. She and her daughters do face the prospect of being penniless in life, if Mr. Bennett dies before the daughters are married. In the early nineteenth century, medicine was much more primitive than it is today; life spans were very short by modern standards; and there was an almost total lack of meaningful economic opportunities for women.

In short, living under the kind of pressure that Mrs. Bennett must have felt could undermine the mental functioning of almost any woman, without having five daughters to provide for.

To be sure, the woman is repugnant. I would hate to be related to her (although I actually was related to a very similar woman with none of Mrs. Bennett's real excuses — a woman whose demise, incidentally, was welcomed by all concerned). But I still feel more than a touch of sympathy for Mrs. Bennett because of the real threat of disaster that was a daily part of her life.

Writing-to-Learn Adventure #1:
The Organizing Adventure of Life
Understand Yourself and Other People and Make Your Love Life Work
Get the Free PDF at Lulu.


Writing-to-Learn Adventure #2:
The Worldview Layer of the Mind
The Key to Surviving, Thriving, and Living the Good Life
(Coming Soon! Also Completely FREE When It's Ready)

This Page Is a New Browser Window.
Manage It Accordingly.

Dr. Hilton's
Writing-to-Learn Adventures

"Have You Found the Organizing Adventure
for Your Life Yet?"



Revised 4/2/2005
© 2005 Joseph N. Hilton
Catalog of Web Pages:
Groundhog Day | Ben Franklin | Grandfather
Home Page | Writing-to-Learn Adventure #1 | About Dr. Hilton